Bigger isn't always better. The Samsung Galaxy Tab 8.9 is pretty much just the Galaxy Tab 10.1 ($499, 3.5 stars), minus 1.2 inches. It's a shrunk-down version of Samsung's flagship
tablet,
at a slightly shrunk-down price: $469 instead of $499. We judge it a
slightly better deal all around and one of the best Android tablets,
although the Apple iPad 2 ($499, 4.5 stars) is still our top tablet choice.
Physical Design and Networking
Samsung is
currently making the best-looking Android tablets in the business,
although its tablets look too much like the iPad for some Apple lawyers'
comfort. The Galaxy Tab 8.9 is no exception; it's a black and silver
slab with no physical buttons on the front, just a bright and
somewhat-reflective 1280-by-800-pixel display; the same resolution as
the larger panel on the Galaxy Tab 10.1. Since the 8.9 is a smaller
screen, the pixels are denser, which is more pleasing to the eye.
The Tab 8.9 is very slim, and
relatively light at 15.7 ounces and 9.1 by 6.2 by .33 inches. There are
power and volume buttons on the top, along with a 3.2-megapixel camera
on the back and a 2-megapixel camera on the front. The back is a smooth
gray plastic; you can't open up the tablet to replace the battery. On
the bottom, along with the stereo speakers, is the single port, a
proprietary docking port.
A Wi-Fi-only tablet, there's no 3G/4G option for the Tab 8.9. You do
get Bluetooth, which supports both mono and stereo audio, and built-in
GPS. In my tests, the 6100 mAh battery powered the tablet for a very
good 8 hours, 15 minutes hours of video playback.
Performance, OS, and Apps
Just like Samsung's
Galaxy Tab 10.1—and a number of other current Android tablets—the 8.9
runs Honeycomb 3.1 on an Nvidia Tegra 2 processor. Benchmark performance
is identical to the 10.1 and to many other Tegra 2-based tablets. I
didn't encounter any bugs, problems, or major slowdowns in my testing.
But there's no schedule for an Android 3.2 update, according to Samsung,
so you should treat this as an Android 3.1 device. The company has
dressed up the interface with TouchWiz, a set of widgets and interface
extensions that seem to slow the tablet down a bit, but make some
activities more convenient.
Samsung throws a bunch of default widgets onto the seven home
screens, which I like because it makes the tablet appear to be more than
just a blank slate. Most of the built-in apps have had subtle aesthetic
redesigns. The Mini Apps Tray is especially welcome: It's a set of six
frequently used apps/widgets which can pop up from the bottom of the
screen. For more on TouchWiz, check out our review of the Galaxy Tab 10.1.
Thus far, Google's Android Market for Honeycomb isn't a winner on
tablet apps, showing too many apps that run poorly on tablets. So along
with the standard Google stuff, Samsung has packed this slate with
tablet-centric stores: its own 7digital-powered music store, both
Samsung's and Google's video stores, and even Samsung's own app store.
As an Nvidia Tegra 2 tablet, the Galaxy Tab also works with Nvidia's Tegra Zone game store.
Unfortunately, none of these stores solve Honeycomb tablets' most
critical problem: not enough apps. Samsung's app store, for instance,
only has from one to five apps in each of its categories. Samsung
insists thousands of phone apps run well on its tablet, but thousands of
others don't, and there's no guide to distinguish them. That makes all
Honeycomb tablets far inferior to the iPad with its 90,000+
well-tailored, tablet-specific apps.
Seven-inch tablets running Honeycomb 3.2, such as the Acer Iconia Tab A100
($329, 4 stars), get around this problem somewhat by presenting phone
apps better than those with larger screens. But bigger tablets without
Honeycomb 3.2's zoom mode give you ugly interfaces when you try to run
many apps designed for Android phones.
The Galaxy Tab syncs contacts and calendars with Samsung's Kies
software on PCs, and lets you drag and drop files in Windows Explorer
onto the tablet. But Mac users should beware: There is no Mac USB
compatibility here.
Multimedia
There are lots of media options to
fill the Tab 8.9's 13.1GB of free storage. (You get no memory card
slot.) Samsung provides the aforementioned 7digital-powered music store
where songs average a dollar each, and a more promising video store
where TV shows cost $1.99, but you can get a bunch of children's and
reality programming for a penny. I downloaded an episode of "Avatar"
(the kids' show, not the movie) and it looked sharp.
All of our sample files played on the Tab, both music and video, and
sounded unusually good through the device's stereo speakers. The Tab
also includes a pair of earbuds, but it has both a standard 3.5-mm
headphone jack and Bluetooth, so you can use whatever headphones you
have lying around.
There's one false note here, though: There's no video out, so you
can't play your movies on a big screen. Samsung advertises a dock with
HDMI out but it's not included with the tablet; the only port here is
the unique dock port, and the only cable you get in the box ends in a
male USB plug.
Streaming video options are mixed. The TV.com app is available, but Hulu and Netflix, notably, aren't.
The Tab's two cameras are both of very good quality. The
3.2-megapixel camera on the back takes razor-sharp, if not terribly
quick photos at 1.1 seconds of shutter delay. The 2-megapixel camera on
the front is similarly sharp. Both cameras record 720P HD video.
Conclusions
The Samsung Galaxy Tab 8.9 is really
just a tweak of the existing 10.1-inch Tab, but that tweak makes it a
bit more appealing. It's a little more portable and a little less
expensive, without losing a pixel of screen resolution, a hertz of
processor speed, or a byte of storage.
That said, we have the same problem with this tablet that we do with
most high-end Android tablets this size: It's going up directly against
the iPad, which has far more apps and a stronger ecosystem. Seven-inch
Android 3.2 tablets at least have the benefits of being more portable
and having phone apps look decent in zoomed mode. But it's hard to argue
why the masses, when presented with this device and an iPad, should
pick the Tab 8.9. If you're not an Apple fan, though, and you want the
thinnest Android tablet you can get, the Tab 8.9 is a solid choice.